Long Sunday
‘You are reserved for a great Monday!’ Fine, but Sunday will never end.—Kafka

« difference without apologies | Main | Handmaids' Tales »

Nation's Snowmen March Against Global Warming

With the current heated discussion regarding the difference between "symbolic politics" and Nationssnowmenc1 "conventional politics" proper, I was reminded of the following fake news item from the Onion.  The Onion is very good at mimicking the sound and feel of how "real news" is presented for our consumption. What seems relevant for our purposes is how the notion of "protesting" is presented as absolutely ridiculous.  The suggestion seems to be that people march and complain for just about anything, with the obligatory appearance by Jesse Jackson added for good measure.  While I generally enjoy the humor (and do not take the Onion too seriously), it does seem to reflect a certain general attitude about politics, particularly of what now may be described as largely "symbolic" expressions of resistance.

For example, in this story of the beleaguered winter figures,"millions of scarfless snowmen and snowwomen gathered in cities across the world Tuesday to raise public awareness about the heavy toll global warming is taking on their health and well-being."  It goes on to quote "Joe Centigrade," president of the Advocates For Beings Of Frozen Precipitation"

"The unseasonably warm winters of the recent past are a clear indication of a real environmental threat to humans and their frozen simulacra," said Centigrade, his coals arranged in a frowning pattern. "As snowmen and snowwomen, we accept the inevitability of melting, but the actions of man are causing us to evaporate well before our time."

Speakers at the Washington rally included a Chicago snowwoman who had lost three snowchildren to warm temperatures, the Rev. Jesse Jackson, and Larry Chilly, formerly a 6-foot-tall, triple-segmented Muncie, IN snowman, who had been reduced to a slushy head.

What I find particularly amusing, but also a bit disturbing, is the parody of rhetorical victimization (that is also the source of so much PC backlash humor):

Bearing signs with such slogans as "You Can't Build A Snowman With Rain" and "Winter = Life," the crystalline-ice protesters, many of whom had chartered refrigerated tractor-trailers and ice-cream trucks to travel to the mass protest, complained that popular stereotypes about snowmen obscure and trivialize the crisis.

Nationssnowmenjumpc1 "Humans sneer at us, 'If you want to stay intact, go to the North Pole and live with Santa,'" said Susie Flakeman, a Thunder Bay, Ontario snowwoman waiting in line with hundreds of others to use a Porta-Freezer. "But less than one-half of 1 percent of us ever receive that honor. Most of us end up victims of the scourge that almost killed Frosty: man-made climate change."

The protest was largely peaceful, disrupted only by a disturbing incident in which one distraught snowman hurled himself into the reflecting pool of the National Mall. He suffered third-degree slush on over 90 percent of his body before rescuers could recover him. He was rushed to a local meat locker where he was pronounced melted on arrival.

My intention in quoting from this fake news story is not that it is wrong to make fun of protests and activism - nothing is really off limits when it comes to humor.  But I do think this piece reflects a larger condition - one that I might call a "Post-Political Cynicism."  From this vantage point, all symbolic politics takes place in the theater of the absurd.  And issues like global warming, something that most scientists take very seriously, is relegated to comical news stories and the concern of granola eating tree huggers.  To get beyond this Post-Political Cynicism will require a vision and an effort that has so far been lacking - one that offers both a practical sensibility of the possible and the inspiration to provide hope in the midst of hopelessness.

By Alain | January 28, 2006 in Post-politics | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/361357/4145807

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Nation's Snowmen March Against Global Warming:

Comments

Thanks for writing about this. At first I was with you all the way, but the original Onion piece really worked for me, and seemed a much pithier satire than it's being credited as here. Let's face it, the realm of symbolic protest really has become a 'theater of the absurd'. That's not just a cynical dismissal but a plaintive admission of my own impotence and frustration at being cannon fodder in other people's lame-ass demonstrations. I usually drum or find a way to engage on my own terms, but demonstrations have long made me feel worse rather than 'empowered' or even just... better.

It's not the point of political protest to assuage the feelings of the participants, and yet too often our feelings are the only thing that seems to change after protesting. So the Onion snowman article seems to do two things well: it actually makes a news-ish point about climate change with a good joke; and it appropriately underscores the impotence and basic irrelevance of the FORM of political protest that we still seem to cling to as the only one that earns visibility.

That does beg the question of what other forms might gain political visibility, or make their political voice heard? Nothing obvious on the horizon yet. But I don't find it irredeemably cynical to joke at the expense of the tired, impotent, repetitive rituals we've inherited from a different political era. We *should* be embarrassed to repeat the same old forms.

All that said, I appreciate that you raise the issue of cynicism as an impediment to political expression. In particular I think our culture habitually equates sincerity with being a chump. To avoid being considered a chump, or a geek, or a fool, you have to strike an ironic pose, a wink-and-nod self-conscious hipness that specifically precludes taking a sincere stance on anything. Very convenient for the status quo, and really crippling for anyone who wants to step up and seek something deeper and better...

I ramble. Thanks for the post.
--cc

Posted by: Chris Carlsson | Jan 29, 2006 2:10:58 AM

I've thought for years that cynicism is the most negative force in our politics, rather than rightism per se. People like PJ O'Rourke and in many respects Rush Limbaugh just assume cynicism. MAny conservative Christians are so cynical about politics that no level of corruption can ever make them angry.

I've got Sloterdijk's cynicism book. So far I haven't liked it much, alas.

Posted by: John Emerson | Jan 29, 2006 10:15:28 AM

Thank you for the response Chris. I largely agree with you. I wrote this in dialogue with the previous post about the effectiveness of symbolic politics, and a larger debate about the merits it had in the past (civil rights, vietnam war). But you are clearly right to point out the obvious: Protests of the "march on Washington" variety have lost their efficacy and do seem to belong to a previous era. I actually thought the piece was funny too. But I had a visceral reaction to the picture of the snowman addressing the crowd in a manner reminiscent of the MLK "I had a Dream Speech." It just reminded me of how cliche and meaningless these forms of expression have become.

John, I read Sloterdijk's cynicism book many years ago and my feeling was much the same. It seemed to do a decent job of expressing the dialectical nature of cynicism as a socio-political phenomenon but that was about it. I do not remember how he thinks we get beyond cynicism or if he even thought we should. And I think you are absolutely correct that Limbaugh and company are completely cynical and that is a key part of their charm - liberal do gooders just make everything worse, we need to rely on ourselves to make our lives better, collective responses are a waiste of time and money, blah, blah, blah.

John I think your point is related to how the conservatives run the government. I recently spoke with someone down in Louisana who is living in a FEMA trailor. She is so bitter about her experience that it has reconfirmed her basic belief "that government can't do anything right." The response to Katrina becomes one more opportunity for the conservatives to chant the Reagan mantra that "government that does least does best."

Posted by: Alain | Jan 29, 2006 11:10:13 AM

So the strategery goes, even.

Posted by: Matt | Jan 29, 2006 12:17:46 PM

Post a comment

Please note: comments are published at the discretion of the post's author and will not appear immediately. Do not submit comments more than once.






 

Technorati Tags: